Pope Leo XIV challenges just war theory in historic consistory
Pope Leo XIV challenges just war theory in historic consistory
Pope Leo XIV challenges just war theory in historic consistory
Pope Leo XIV recently held his second consistory, gathering 178 cardinals to address pressing issues facing the Church. The meeting centred on his first encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas, and its implications for modern challenges. Topics included the future of Catholic teaching on war, the role of artificial intelligence, and the implementation of synodality. During the consistory, Pope Leo declared that the traditional 'just war' theory is now outdated. In his homily to the cardinals, he stated that war is 'never blessed by God'. Cardinal Robert W. McElroy later suggested that the Church must still clarify when military force could be morally permissible.
The cardinals also explored how to apply the encyclical’s principles across the Church. Artificial intelligence was highlighted as a growing challenge requiring careful consideration. Synodality, a key theme of the discussions, was emphasised by Cardinal McElroy as essential at every level, especially in decision-making.
A proposal to issue a collective statement endorsing Pope Leo’s stance on war was tabled. However, the cardinals chose not to proceed, as not all members were present to contribute to the decision. The consistory concluded with a focus on how the Church will move forward with its teachings and practices. Pope Leo’s encyclical and the discussions on synodality and AI signal a period of reflection for Catholic leadership. The Church now faces the task of translating these debates into action.